Your Child Isn't Giving You a Hard Time. They're Having a Hard Time—But With What?

When a child argues about every instruction, refuses to start homework, procrastinates until the last possible minute, shuts down, or completely falls apart over something that seems small, it can be hard not to focus on the behavior.

Why are they making this so difficult?

There’s a phrase used in parenting and education that offers a helpful shift in perspective:

“Your child isn’t giving you a hard time. They’re having a hard time.”

I like that idea because it moves us away from assuming that difficult behavior is intentionally designed to make our lives difficult. It invites us to become curious about what is happening for the child.

But I think we need to take it one step further.

They’re having a hard time—with what?

Because “having a hard time” still isn’t an explanation.

Defiance is something we observe.Avoidance is something we observe.Procrastination is something we observe.Shutting down is something we observe.An emotional explosion is something we observe.

They tell us that something isn’t working. They don’t tell us what.

And that distinction matters. If we can figure out what demand the child is struggling to meet, we have a much better chance of knowing what to do next.

Behavior Is the Part We Can See

Imagine a child sitting at the kitchen table staring at a blank document. His parent has reminded him three times to begin his English paper. He sighs. Complains. Gets up for water. Checks his phone. Suddenly remembers something he needs upstairs. Eventually, when his parent pushes harder, he snaps:

“I KNOW! Leave me alone!”

From the outside, this looks like procrastination and attitude. But what is actually hard?

That is the question that matters.

Maybe he doesn't understand the assignment.

Maybe he has plenty of ideas but can't organize them.

Maybe he doesn't know how to write the first sentence.

Maybe the assignment feels so large that he can't identify a starting point.

Maybe he is worried that what he writes won't be good enough.

Maybe sustaining attention for a long writing task takes enormous effort.

Maybe he is exhausted after holding himself together all day.

Or maybe he simply does not want to write the paper—and has not yet developed the self-management skills to make himself do something unpleasant because it needs to be done. Those are very different problems. And they require very different solutions.

Ask About the Demand, Not Just the Behavior

When behavior repeatedly goes off track, I encourage parents to ask:

What is this situation asking my child to do that is difficult for them right now?

That question changes the investigation.

Instead of:

Why is she being so difficult?

we ask:

What demand is she struggling to meet?

• A transition requires a child to stop one thing, shift attention, manage disappointment, and begin something else.

• Homework requires a child to remember the assignment, gather materials, estimate time, get started, sustain effort, tolerate mistakes, and finish.

• Getting ready for school requires sequencing, time awareness, working memory, organization, and resistance to distraction.

• A difficult social situation can require reading cues, managing emotions, considering another person's perspective, inhibiting an immediate reaction, and figuring out what to say.

• “Clean your room” sounds like one instruction to an adult. To some children, it is twenty decisions with no obvious starting point.

Once we look at the demand underneath the behavior, what seemed inexplicable often begins to make sense.

Same Behavior. Different Reasons.

This is also why we have to be careful about assuming that a particular behavior always means the same thing.

Consider avoidance.

One child avoids reading because reading is genuinely difficult. Another avoids it because sustained attention is difficult. Another is afraid of making mistakes. Another has learned that if she waits long enough, an adult will sit beside her and walk her through it. And another would simply rather play a video game.

All five children are avoiding. But “avoidance” isn't the explanation. It is the clue.

The same is true for an emotional explosion. Was the child overwhelmed? Embarrassed? Hungry and exhausted? Unable to shift away from something highly preferred? Caught off guard by an unexpected change? Frustrated because something felt unfair? Holding it together all day and finally out of resources? Trying to escape a demand that has successfully disappeared after previous explosions? Again, what we see on the outside can look remarkably similar while what is happening underneath is very different.

Understanding Doesn't Mean Excusing

This is an important distinction.

Looking underneath behavior does not mean children shouldn't have expectations, responsibilities, or consequences. Understanding why a child is struggling does not mean saying:

“Oh, this is hard for you, so you don't have to do it.”

Often, it means exactly the opposite.

Now we know what needs to be taught.

If starting is the problem, we help build a starting routine.

If organization is the problem, we make the steps visible.

If anxiety is driving avoidance, continually removing the demand can actually strengthen the anxiety. Instead, we help the child learn that discomfort is tolerable and that they can move through it.

If frustration tolerance is weak, we don't eliminate every frustrating experience. We provide manageable opportunities to practice handling frustration.

If a child has learned that arguing for twenty minutes eventually makes a parent give up, understanding that pattern tells us something important too.

Compassion and expectations are not opposites.

Children need both.

Look for the Bottleneck

I often think of this as finding the bottleneck.

The whole task doesn't have to be difficult. Sometimes there is one point where everything gets stuck.

• A child knows how to do the math but can't get started.

• A teenager can complete an assignment but repeatedly forgets to submit it.

• A child can handle a change in plans if given warning but falls apart when the change is unexpected.

• A student understands the material but freezes when asked to perform under pressure.

• A child wants friends but struggles to recognize when a joke has gone too far.

The bottleneck tells us where help is needed.

And importantly, we don't want to provide ten supports when the child needs one.

The goal isn't to make life easier at every turn.

It is to figure out where the path is breaking down and strengthen that part of the path.

Become a Detective

When something repeatedly isn't working, try becoming curious before becoming corrective.

You can ask yourself:

What happened immediately before this?

What was my child being asked to do?

Where did things begin to fall apart?

Does this happen every time, or only under certain conditions?

Can my child do this when interested but not when bored?

Is the task too difficult—or simply unpleasant?

Does my child know what to do but struggle to make themselves do it?

Is anxiety getting in the way?

Is there a skill that I am assuming is already there?

And one of my favorites:

What would have to be easier for this to go better?

You won't always know the answer immediately. That's okay. Patterns give us information.

From “What's Wrong?” to “What's Hard?”

One of the most useful changes in thinking we can make as parents, educators, and clinicians is moving away from:

“What's wrong with this child?”

and even from:

“Why won't they just do it?”

toward:

“What's hard about this?”

Then we keep going.

What specifically is hard?

Is it starting?

Stopping?

Remembering?

Organizing?

Waiting?

Shifting?

Managing uncertainty?

Tolerating frustration?

Understanding what is expected?

Doing something boring?

Recovering from a mistake?

Asking for help?

Accepting “no”?

The more precisely we can identify the problem, the more precisely we can respond.

Behavior Is Communication—but We Still Have to Translate It

I believe strongly that behavior is communication.

But communication still has to be interpreted. A slammed door doesn't come with subtitles. Neither does procrastination, refusal, shutting down, yelling, or “I don't care.”

Our job isn't to automatically excuse the behavior or immediately punish it. Our job is to get curious enough to understand what is happening, while still helping children develop the skills and responsibility they need.

So the next time your child seems to be giving you a hard time, remember the familiar phrase:

Maybe they're having a hard time.

And then ask the question that makes the phrase useful:

With what?

Because that's where understanding begins—and where effective intervention can begin, too.

---

The Control Tower Model™

See their strengths.

Understand their brain.

Strengthen the Control Tower.

---

If you would like to learn more about how to build an external brain or the Control Tower Model, check out my book ADHD: The Comprehensive Parent's Guide,